Debt Consolidation
vs. Bankruptcy

If dealing with bills and creditors has become overwhelming, you may be wondering whether debt consolidation or bankruptcy would be the better way to get you out of debt.  The answer is complex and depends on your individual situation and factors such as your income, employment, assets, and whether you own a home.

Both bankruptcy and debt consolidation have benefits and disadvantages. Before you choose, you should be aware of the process involved and the long-term effects of each.

The skilled and seasoned Ohio debt-relief attorneys at Fesenmyer Cousino Weinzimmer understand that financial problems can happen to even the most well-intentioned people.  We offer a free consultation to evaluate your entire financial situation – your income, your debts and your goals — and see what solutions are right for you.

Debt Consolidation

Debt consolidation involves taking out a new loan to pay off several older debts.  The idea is to have a lower interest rate and longer period to pay off the new debt than you had for the old ones. You start by contacting a debt consolidation service, which becomes the middleman between you and your creditors and negotiates reduced payments.

Once your consolidation is set up, you make one monthly payment to the consolidation company and they pay your creditors, so you no longer have to deal with them. You can consolidate debt through a secured loan (usually secured by equity in your home) or an unsecured loan, where the consolidator simply lends you the money.

You may also be able to lower your cost of credit by consolidating your debt through a second mortgage or a home equity line of credit. However, if you default, you put your home at risk if you have more equity in your home than you are allowed to protect with your Ohio home exemption.

Advantages of Debt Consolidation

  • It protects your reputation and credit rating. Debt consolidation is not a matter of public record. It may show up on your credit report, but it does not typically lower a credit score like a bankruptcy filing does.
  • You keep your credit.  Usually, unless the terms of your loan do not allow it, you can keep your credit cards. However, if you keep running up charges on credit cards, you will be back in a financial hole.
  • Simplifies your payments. You just have to make one payment for the consolidation loan.
  • Has lower interest rate and monthly payment. But be aware of costs and fees of some loans, as well as tax liability that could actually make costs higher.

Disadvantages of Debt Consolidation

  • Risk to property. For loans secured by your home or vehicle, you could lose that property if you default on the consolidation loan.
  • Hidden costs. Debt consolidation services charge a small monthly fee, primarily for administrative costs. Costs and fees of some loans, as well as tax liability, could actually make total costs higher in the long run. So can extending the repayment period.
  • Tax consequences. The IRS may consider money you save from debt consolidation as income, which, depending on your income, may mean you pay taxes on it.
  • Creditors may end plans. Consolidation agreements are not typically legally binding, so if creditors change their mind about accepting lower payments, they can end the payment plan.


Bankruptcy allows you to eliminate or restructure certain debts while under the protection of the federal bankruptcy court. The most common types are Chapter 7 and Chapter 13.

A Chapter 7 bankruptcy allows you to eliminate many types of debt quickly and receive a fresh start.

A Chapter 13 bankruptcy allows you to reorganize assets and consolidate your payments to avoid fees and fines and repay some or all of your debt affordably over a three- to five-year period. If you successfully complete the court-approved payment plan, the debts covered by the plan are discharged.

Advantages of Filing for Bankruptcy

  • Protection from creditors. When you file for bankruptcy in Ohio, there is an automatic stay that prohibits most creditors and collectors from engaging in collection activity such as harassing phone calls, lawsuits, garnishments, repossessions, and foreclosures.
  • Provides a fresh start. Chapter 7 bankruptcy eliminates most unsecured debt such as medical bills and credit cards. Ohio’s exemptions may allow you to keep much of your property. Chapter 13 bankruptcy lets you repay a portion of your unsecured debts through the court-supervised repayment plan. You typically pay only a percentage of your total debt, and you may be able to save your home from foreclosure and your vehicle from repossession. Through the Chapter 13 repayment plan, you pay a trustee who distributes money to your creditors, and you no longer have to deal with them.
  • Re-establish your credit. The discharge of a bankruptcy helps to give you a fresh start.  It clears out negative reporting so that you can start to rebuild your credit.  Once a debt is discharged through bankruptcy, the default statuses are cleared and the credit score will increase.  Lenders are more likely to lend to someone who is not in default on their debt payments.

Disadvantages of Filing for Bankruptcy

  • Credit rating. A bankruptcy initially lowers your credit score and may stay on your credit report for seven to ten years. However, once you receive your bankruptcy discharge, you will have a clean slate, and since there are time limits on filing for bankruptcy again, it may actually be easier to get credit. In general, a credit score usually increases from 60 to 100+ points a year after the discharge.
  • Privacy and reputation. Your employer may learn about your bankruptcy if you permit it to pull your credit report or if your Chapter 13 plan payments are made through payroll deductions. Also, bankruptcy records are available to others at the federal bankruptcy courthouse and through the federal court system’s PACER service.

Contact Us and Get Help

The experienced and compassionate Ohio bankruptcy attorneys at Fesenmyer Cousino Weinzimmer; know what it is like to struggle with financial problems and will help you find a solution.  Take the first step toward debt relief and CONTACT US TODAY FOR A FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION.

During your consultation, we will evaluate your entire financial situation and determine whether bankruptcy or debt consolidation is the best fit for you.  We will make sure you are aware of all your options and will walk you through the process.

Delaying can only worsen your situation, so call the Ohio bankruptcy attorneys at Fesenmyer Cousino Weinzimmer today!  Call one of our conveniently located office branches at 614-228-4435 (Columbus), 937-222-7472 (Dayton), or 877-654-5297 (Cincinnati) or email for your free consultation so we can determine what debt relief solutions will work best for you.

In uncertain times, a person can become overwhelmed by debt and default on their payments. This is especially true if you face unexpected circumstances like job loss, natural disaster, or a devastating medical diagnosis. So…

There is an alarming trend that is growing in America, and it has been made worse by COVID-19 in 2020.  More and more older Americans and retirees are burdened with significant debt.  A recent study…

Does bankruptcy disqualify you for a job? If you’re overwhelmed by debt and are considering the proactive step of filing for bankruptcy so you can get a fresh start, you may have several questions. One…

Columbus, Ohio Law Firm